The Finance Ministry insists that GST rate rationalisation is about easing the burden on the common man — not revenue loss. Yet, analysts and economists remain unconvinced about the government’s estimate of a ₹48,000 crore shortfall.
The ministry projects a gross revenue loss of ₹93,000 crore, offset by ₹45,000 crore in gains from shifting some goods into the new 40% slab. These figures are based on FY24 consumption and static assumptions. Officials argue that consumption growth will eventually balance out the losses. “Whether it is ₹48,000 crore or ₹93,000 crore, this money stays with the people,” a senior official told TNIE.
But independent estimates paint a grimmer picture. Former finance secretary Subhash Chandra Garg calls the government’s numbers “gross under-estimation.” By his calculation, adjusted for 2025-26 prices, losses could touch ₹1.1 lakh crore annually, with an additional ₹1.4 lakh crore forgone due to the end of GST compensation cess. Even after clawing back ₹50,000 crore via the 40% slab, Garg sees a net gap close to ₹2 lakh crore.
Brokerages agree. Reports from Emkay Global, HSBC, and Bernstein peg the eventual hit at ₹1.5–2 lakh crore. Bernstein’s breakdown shows merging the 12% slab into 5% could cost ₹79,600 crore, while eliminating the 28% slab may cut another ₹1.12 lakh crore. Gains from upward shifts — ₹700 crore (12% to 18%) and ₹15,000 crore (28% to 40%) — barely move the needle, leaving a net loss of ₹1.57 lakh crore. HSBC pegs the six-month impact at ₹57,000 crore.
IDFC First Bank’s chief economist Gaura Sengupta offered a somewhat lower figure of ₹95,000 crore, noting the fiscal strain will be heavier on states since the Centre shares 41% of CGST.
Meanwhile, Emkay Global warns the Centre’s tax collections are already lagging. Gross tax revenue growth for April–July FY26 was just 0.8% against a budget target of 13%, raising doubts about meeting ambitious buoyancy goals. Temporary relief could come from higher RBI dividends, PSU payouts, or stake sales in IDBI and state-run banks.
While the government downplays fiscal risks, most experts agree the true cost of GST reforms could be far higher than the official estimate.
Here are six affordable blushes under Rs 1,000 that add the perfect flush of colour… Read More
Here are five lip & cheek tint shades under Rs 1,000 that look universally flattering. Read More
The H3N2 influenza virus is driving a rise in flu infections in 2025. With symptoms… Read More
Why Monsoon Aggravates Oily Skin The rainy season brings relief from summer heat but also… Read More
Sarv Moksha Amavasya 2025 falls on 21 September, Sunday. Know the exact timings, auspicious muhurat… Read More
From sugar and stress to smoking and sleepless nights, these daily habits can quietly damage… Read More